Selvdisciplin hos postere

Jeg efterlyser lidt mere selvdisciplin!

Jeg synes, der bliver postet for mange ubrugelige svar, når folk svarer i hand-analysis tråde. Det ville være rart, om der kom konstruktive svar, der eventuelt ledte til konstruktive diskussioner, på de spørgsmål folk nu stillede i stedet for fuldstændigt ligegyldige svar, som: 'Fold', 'ryk ned i limet' og den slags.

Derudeover kunne det generelt blive nogle langt mere interessante tråde, hvis folk holdte personligt ævl og kævl ude samtidig.
Det er selvfølgelig fair nok, hvis man vil oprette OT-tråde til brug for ævl og kævl, men skæg for sig og snot for sig!

Jeg har sakset nogle retningslinjer fra et andet forum, som jeg synes giver god mening:


TIPS FOR RESPONDING IN HAND THREADS

--Be kind.
--Include the reasoning of your analysis, even if it's brief.

Bad: Raise more pf.
Good: Your hand plays best heads-up, but your preflop raise was too small to get the job done. Try raising to $6 instead of $3.

Bad: Push river.
Good: Pooosh. Villian likes his hand. You have the second nuts. If he's got quads, oh well.

Bad: You're too stupid to play SSNL. Try checkers instead.
Good: Bad on every street. 1/4-pot flop bet was purposeless, turn call was horrible given your odds, then you suckout on the river and get no value.

Bad: You can't call this turn.
Good: You can't call this turn because your opponent is WAY to passive to start betting here without the flush, and you don't have the odds to chase anymore.

Bad: Raise the flop.
Good: Raise the flop to $18 to protect your hand.

--Discussion is good. Questions are good. It's better to ask in a hand thread a totally n00b question (Why did you PFR this hand from MP?) than it is to start a whole new thread about it. Also, just repeating what 10 previous people have already said is useless.

It's always amusing and aggravating when you have a 2-day long thread going with many, many nuggets of gold in it, and where the discussion has evolved into something very interesting; and someone comes out the blue in response #97 and repeats a simplistic comment that was made back in response #3. They didn't read the thread and are basically just selfishly talking only to make themselves heard.

Read the whole thread. If you don't have anything to add, don't. If you have questions, ask. If you have a new angle of analysis, bring it. If you disagree with some of the posters in the thread, air it out. Discuss. Rinse, repeat.

SSNL gets hit-n-run all the time by newbie posters. They post a few hands and are never heard from again. They think if they can play the specific hand they posted better, they will have learned all they need to know. IMHO, most of the learning around here comes from the act of discussing itself. Talking about NLHE challenges your perceptions of the game and refines the truth that you already know. If you are a n00b to SSNL, you will be much better served responding in existing hand threads, than beginning too many of your own.